The Great Canadian Baking Show Season 5 “Cookie Week” Recap

Last week, we kicked off another season of baking fun and said goodbye to Kunal. From the first week, two front runners have emerged: Steve and Aimee. Can the two keep up their momentum in cookie week or will they falter? Who else will become a front runner for the final three.

Let us find out as we start cookie week.

Signature Bake

The Bake: 12 Ice Box Sandwich Cookies that are are colourful with an intricate design and filling

The Time: 2 hours and 15 minutes.

What I would bake: Mocha Ice Box Sandwich cookies with a chocolate-orange buttercream to look like an Ewok.

What the contestants baked and judges thoughts:

All the sandwich cookies the bakers made, I am most intrigued by Aimee’s as I do love the flavours she has chosen and it is an interesting take on a sandwich ice book cookie. The next ones that I wouldn’t mind trying, flavour-wise, are Stephen’s and Alina’s 

  • Caron: Passionate for Passionfruit Cookies made with passionfruit sugar cookies and milk chocolate ganache. Bruno said she nailed the passionfruit flavour but Kyla said it could use a bit longer in the oven.
  • Stephen: Strawberry Lemonade Cookies with strawberry mint buttercream. Bruno liked the strawberry flavour and Kyla said it epitomized summer
  • Aimee: Savoury Sandwich Cookies made with brown butter sesame cookie and prosciutto brie and fig jam. Kyla called the flavours classic but presented in an original way.
  • Dougal: Zesty Blueberry Cookies made with lime sugar cookies and blueberry jam and cream cheese frosting. Bruno said the baking looks inconsistent. Kyla said the jam should be a bit more thick.
  • Marian: Kek Lapis Cookies made with black tea and ginger sugar cookies and milk toffee caramel. Kyla suggested an egg wash glaze and some parts were under-baked. Bruno liked the ginger flavour.
  • Alina: Toy Block Cookies made with vanilla and rum sugar cookies and espresso ganache. Bruno said she nailed the coffee flavour.
  • Amanda: Perfectly Pear Cookies made with ginger and vanilla cookies and pear buttercream. Kyla liked the presentation and Bruno said the pear flavour is lost.
  • Steve: Lemon and Raspberry Cookies made with lemon and thyme sugar cookies, raspberry jam, and white chocolate ganache. Bruno said the star is the raspberry jam.
  • Vincent: Garden of Roses Cookies made with rose water sugar cookies and chocolate ganache. Bruno liked the crunch. Kyla liked the balance the raspberry brings.

Technical Bake I wanted to make last week’s lamingtons as I pretty much have all the ingredients except the raspberries but this weekend is my birthday weekend and I made my birthday cake instead and that pretty much took a lot of energy out of me as I also made a pavlova from the egg white I had left over from the cake. 

I probably won’t try this week’s technical again because I have buttermilk that I need to use by next week and I have three bakes in mind to make. 

Also, peeling the skin of hazelnuts is a pain and I don’t feel like dirtying a kitchen towl.

The Bake: 20 Pirouette Cookies with a chocolate hazelnut filling

The Time: 2 hours

How I would have fared: Probably not well. I think my issue would be getting it the right thickness and then the rolling and also ensuring that I don’t break the cookies as I fill them.

How the bakers did:

  1. 1st Place

  2. Caron
  3. Amanda
  4. Vincent
  5. Aimee
  6. Stephen
  7. Dougal
  8. Alina:
  9. Steve


The Bake: Cookie Mosaic – use colourful cookie tiles to create a decorative image on a large cookie base

The Time: 4 hours.

What I would bake: I like the idea of a chocolate chip cookie base so I would go with that for my base. As for design, I would do tetris made with spiced chai sugar cookies. 

What the contestants baked and judges thoughts:

Flavour-wise, I like Steve’s and I actually like the idea of a chocolate chip cookie base. 

  • Caron: Cookie Rainbow Estate made with genmaicha sugar cookie tiles on a gingerbread base. Kyla called the look dynamic and like the spice of the genmaicha cookie.
  • Stephen: Achy Bakey Heart made with orange cardamom sugar cookie tiles on a brown butter chocolate chip cookie base. Kyla could eat the whole thing by herself.
  • Aimee: Vintage Cookie Lamp made with vanilla langue de chat tiles on a digestive biscuit base. Kyla wants the lamp in her living room. Bruno called her base cookie so good. 
  • Dougal: Buzzworthy Mosaic made with ginger honey cookie tiles on an oatcake base. Bruno called the look busy. Kyla liked the honey and Bruno liked the cookie.
  • Marian: Window into Bahrain Mosaic made with cardamom saffron cookie tiles on a coffee cinnamon cookie base. Bruno liked the rustic look. Kyla said it could use more time in the oven.
  • Alina: Postcard from Santorini mad with orange shortbread tiles on a lemon sugar cookie base. Bruno said the cookie has too much salt but Kyla liked the story told.
  • Amanda: Cookie Map of PEI made with lemon poppy seed cookie tiles on an espresso cardamom sugar cookie base. Bruno calls it a love letter to PEI. Kyla says it has crunch and bursts of flavour. 
  • Steve: Easy Rider Mosaic made with ginger shortbread tiles with orange cream cheese buttercream on top of a chocolate chip cookie base. Bruno liked the story his mosaic told. Bruno liked how the cream cheese made the cookie soft.
  • Cookie Week Star Baker

    Vincent: Lotus Garden made with coconut sugar cookie tiles and lime royal icing on a gingerbread cookie base. Kyla calls it striking and liked the balance of the lime and coconut.

Marian: Going Home

Up for Star Baker: Aimee, Vincent and Steve

In danger of going home: Marian and Caron

Star Baker: Aimee

Going Home: Marian

Quick Thoughts: It was a close call for Caron. I hope Caron pulls it together to have a long run. But based on cookie week, Aimee and Steve continue to be front-runners and Vincent is looking like the one to join those two into the final three.

About Vanessa Ho (1069 Articles)
Pop culture addicts' view of the world of TV

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: